Imagine a giant, toothy fish exploding from the water’s surface, chasing your lure! That’s the thrilling moment a musky hunter lives for, especially when using topwater lures. But choosing the right topwater lure can feel like trying to catch lightning in a bottle. There are so many colors, shapes, and sizes, and it’s tough to know which one will actually get a bite.
Many anglers waste time and money on lures that just don’t work. They get frustrated when the fish ignore their offerings, and they wonder what they’re doing wrong. This guide is here to change that! We’ll break down the secrets of topwater musky fishing, helping you understand what makes a lure irresistible to these powerful predators.
By the end of this post, you’ll know how to pick the perfect topwater lure for any situation. You’ll learn about different lure types and when to use them. Get ready to boost your confidence and start seeing more explosive strikes. Let’s dive in and discover the topwater lures that will help you land that trophy musky!
Our Top 5 Topwater Musky Lures Recommendations at a Glance
| Image | Product | Rating | Links |
|---|---|---|---|
 |
TRUSCEND PoPobait with BKK Hooks | 9.0/10 | Check Price |
 |
Creek Chub Jointed Pikie Fishing Lure for Large Bass | 8.9/10 | Check Price |
 |
Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Topwater Fishing Lure | 9.2/10 | Check Price |
 |
VMSIXVM Duck Lures for Bass Fishing | 9.4/10 | Check Price |
 |
10in Large Topwater Multi Jointed Fishing Lures Bait | 9.4/10 | Check Price |
Top 5 Topwater Musky Lures Detailed Reviews
1. TRUSCEND PoPobait with BKK Hooks
Rating: 9.1/10
The TRUSCEND PoPobait is a topwater fishing lure designed to bring exciting action to your fishing trips. Its unique design mimics a real fish, making it irresistible to a variety of freshwater and saltwater species. This lure is a fantastic choice for anglers looking to add some splash and excitement to their next fishing adventure.
What We Like:
- The blade’s unique design creates a loud sputter, attracting fish from a distance.
- It’s “roll resistant,” meaning it stays steady even when you reel fast.
- The tail design helps keep fish from spitting out the lure once they bite.
- Extra weight in the belly helps you cast farther with ease.
- The lure has realistic 3D eyes and hand-painted scales that look like a real fish.
- It’s made of strong ABS material and comes with sharp, rust-proof BKK hooks.
- This lure works for many fish like bass, catfish, walleye, pike, and perch.
- It’s a great gift idea for any fishing enthusiast in the family.
What Could Be Improved:
- While effective, the lure’s “plopping” sound might be too noisy for some super-skittish fish in very clear, calm water.
- The lure is designed to float, so it won’t work for anglers who prefer to fish deeper below the surface.
This TRUSCEND PoPobait lure promises a thrilling fishing experience with its realistic design and attention-grabbing action. It’s a versatile and high-quality option for any angler looking to improve their catch rate.
2. Creek Chub Jointed Pikie Fishing Lure for Large Bass
Rating: 9.4/10
When you’re after the big ones, you need a lure that can handle the challenge. The Creek Chub Jointed Pikie Fishing Lure is designed for exactly that. This 6-inch, 1 3/4 ounce lure is a powerhouse, built to attract and catch large bass, striper, musky, and pike. Its tough plastic construction means it can take a beating, and its sturdy hardware is made to last through many fishing trips.
What We Like:
- It’s incredibly effective at attracting big predatory fish like pike and muskie.
- The jointed design gives it a lifelike swimming action that big fish can’t resist.
- It works great for both casting and trolling, giving you options for different fishing styles.
- It can dive to depths of 4-7 feet when casting and an impressive 11 feet when trolling.
- The lure is made from tough plastic polymer, so it’s built to be durable and withstand tough conditions.
- The hardware is sturdy and made for the long haul.
What Could Be Improved:
- While tough, the joint might be a point of weakness over extreme, prolonged use with very large, powerful fish, though this is rare.
- Its size and weight might be a bit much for anglers targeting smaller game fish.
If you’re serious about landing trophy-sized fish, the Creek Chub Jointed Pikie is a lure you need in your tackle box. It’s a reliable choice for chasing down your next personal best.
3. Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Topwater Fishing Lure
Rating: 9.0/10
The Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper Topwater Fishing Lure is a serious tool for anglers targeting big fish. This lure, in a striking Pearl Red Head color, measures 7 inches and weighs 2 ounces. It’s designed to get the attention of trophy catches in freshwater environments.
What We Like:
- It comes in 6 and 7-inch sizes, making it great for catching big fish.
- The weighted tail helps it cast really far and creates exciting action in the water.
- This lure is super versatile. It’s famous for catching striped bass, but it works for many other large game fish too.
- It’s built tough to handle strong fish like stripers, bass, musky, and redfish.
- You can use the “Walk the Dog” technique with it. This makes the lure move in a lifelike way that really attracts fish.
What Could Be Improved:
- While tough, the finish might show wear after many battles with large fish.
- The bright Pearl Red Head color, while attractive, might not be ideal in all water clarity conditions.
If you’re looking to land your next personal best, the Cotton Cordell Pencil Popper is a lure that deserves a spot in your tackle box. Its design and action are built for success when the big ones are biting.
4. VMSIXVM Duck Lures for Bass Fishing
Rating: 9.1/10
Get ready for some serious action with the VMSIXVM Duck Lures! These topwater baits are designed to look like realistic baby ducklings, making them a tempting target for hungry predator fish. Whether you’re fishing in freshwater lakes or saltwater bays, these lures are built to attract a wide variety of game fish. The lifelike swimming action and bright colors are sure to turn heads and get those bites.
What We Like:
- These lures look super real, just like baby ducks swimming.
- They have lively legs and tails that make them move naturally in the water, creating a bubble trail that attracts fish.
- The hooks are really sharp and made of strong steel, so they grab fish well and don’t rust.
- They work for many kinds of fish like bass, pike, catfish, and more!
- You can use them in both fresh and saltwater.
- They come in two bright colors, yellow and green, to grab attention.
What Could Be Improved:
- While the realism is great, sometimes a more subtle approach is needed for very wary fish.
- The size is good for many fish, but a smaller or larger option might be useful for different fishing situations.
If you want to add some fun and excitement to your fishing trips, these duck lures are a fantastic choice. They’re designed to bring in the big ones and make your fishing experience more successful and enjoyable.
5. 10in Large Topwater Multi Jointed Fishing Lures Bait
Rating: 8.8/10
Unleash the big catches with the 10in Large Topwater Multi Jointed Fishing Lures Bait. This impressive lure is designed to attract giant fish. Its multi-jointed body creates a realistic swimming action that fish can’t resist. The bright colors and lifelike details make it look like a real meal swimming through the water.
What We Like:
- Giant Size: At 10.24 inches long and weighing 3.8 ounces, this lure is perfect for targeting big game fish.
- Realistic Action: The four-segment design lets the lure wiggle and dance like a real fish, attracting attention.
- Casts Far: The built-in steel ball helps you cast the lure a long distance, so you can reach more spots.
- Loud Noise: The noise-making feature helps fish sense the lure from further away, even in murky water.
- Tough Build: Made from strong ABS plastic, this lure can handle tough fights. The sharp, rust-proof treble hooks are ready to grab.
- Looks Real: The 3D eyes and detailed finish make it look just like a live fish, fooling even the smartest predators.
What Could Be Improved:
- Size for Smaller Fish: Its large size might be too much for smaller fish species.
- Durability in Extreme Conditions: While high quality, prolonged use against very large, powerful fish might test its long-term durability.
This lure is a powerful tool for any angler looking to land their next trophy. Get ready for some exciting fishing action!
Topwater Musky Lures: Your Guide to Surface Strikes
Topwater musky lures bring the thrill of a surface explosion to your fishing trips. Watching a giant musky launch out of the water to smash your lure is an unforgettable experience. This guide helps you choose the best topwater lures to make that happen.
Key Features to Look For
When picking a topwater musky lure, several features make a big difference.
Action
The lure’s movement in the water is crucial. Some lures “walk the dog” with a side-to-side wobble. Others pop and splash, creating commotion. A lure that mimics a struggling baitfish often works best.
Size and Profile
Muskies are big predators. They often chase large prey. Look for lures that are at least 6 inches long, and some can be over a foot! A bulky profile can look like a substantial meal.
Sound and Vibration
Some lures have rattles or create a lot of splash. This noise can attract muskies from far away. The vibrations they send through the water can also trigger a strike.
Color
Bright colors like chartreuse and white can be great on sunny days. Natural colors like black and silver work well when the water is murky or on cloudy days. Think about what baitfish live in the lake you’re fishing.
Important Materials
The materials used in a lure affect its durability and how it performs.
Body Material
Many topwater lures have bodies made of hard plastic. This is common for poppers and walkers. Some larger, more realistic lures might use soft plastic or even wood. Wood lures can be very durable and have a classic look.
Hooks
Strong, sharp treble hooks are essential. You need hooks that can handle the power of a musky. Look for corrosion-resistant hooks, especially if you fish in saltwater or brackish water.
Hardware
The split rings and line ties should be strong. They connect your lure to your fishing line. These parts need to be able to withstand a lot of pressure.
Factors That Improve or Reduce Quality
Quality matters when you’re after a trophy musky.
Build Quality
A well-made lure will last longer. Check for good paint jobs that don’t chip easily. The components should be securely attached. A lure that falls apart after a few fish isn’t a good investment.
Balancing
A balanced lure will perform its intended action consistently. If a lure is poorly balanced, it might roll over or not move correctly. This can make it less attractive to fish.
Durability
Musky fishing can be tough on lures. They get hit hard. Lures made with robust materials and strong construction will hold up better over time.
User Experience and Use Cases
Topwater lures are exciting to use in specific situations.
When to Use Topwater
Topwater lures shine in warmer water, typically from late spring through early fall. Calm, clear mornings and evenings are prime times. They are also great when you can see the fish or when you know muskies are active near the surface.
Where to Use Topwater
These lures excel in shallow water, over weed beds, and around structure like fallen trees. They can also be effective in open water if muskies are actively chasing baitfish near the surface.
The Thrill of the Strike
Using a topwater lure offers a visual fishing experience. You see the strike happen right before your eyes. This makes for an adrenaline rush unlike any other. It’s a style of fishing that is both visually engaging and incredibly rewarding.
Frequently Asked Questions (FAQ)
Q: What is the best time of year to use topwater musky lures?
A: The best time is usually when the water is warm, from late spring to early fall. Warm water makes muskies more active near the surface.
Q: How big should a topwater musky lure be?
A: Muskies are large fish. Lures that are at least 6 inches long are good. Some anglers even use lures over a foot long.
Q: What kind of action should I look for in a topwater lure?
A: Look for lures that wobble, “walk the dog,” or create a lot of splash and noise. These actions mimic injured prey and attract attention.
Q: Do colors matter for topwater musky lures?
A: Yes, colors matter. Bright colors like chartreuse work well in clear, sunny conditions. Natural colors like black and silver are good for murky water or cloudy days.
Q: What materials are common for topwater musky lures?
A: Many are made of hard plastic. Some larger, more realistic ones might be made of soft plastic or wood.
Q: Why is hook quality important for musky lures?
A: Muskies have powerful jaws and fight hard. You need strong, sharp hooks that won’t bend or break when you hook a big fish.
Q: When should I consider using a topwater lure over other types?
A: Use topwater lures when you know muskies are feeding near the surface, especially in warmer water and shallow areas.
Q: What is “walking the dog” action?
A: “Walking the dog” is a lure action where it moves from side to side with a rhythmic wobble, like a dog on a leash.
Q: Can topwater lures be used in any type of water?
A: They work best in freshwater, but some anglers adapt them for saltwater or brackish environments. However, they are most commonly associated with freshwater musky fishing.
Q: How do I make a topwater lure more effective?
A: Experiment with different retrieves. Vary your speed and pause. Sometimes a slow, steady retrieve works, and other times erratic action triggers a strike. Pay attention to how the lure acts.
In conclusion, every product has unique features and benefits. We hope this review helps you decide if it meets your needs. An informed choice ensures the best experience.
If you have any questions or feedback, please share them in the comments. Your input helps everyone. Thank you for reading.
I’m the recipe developer and food photographer behind Air Fryer at Tiffany’s. I’m also a wife, mom to two adventurous little boys, registered nurse, and live in the great Midwest. Join me as I show you new ways to use your air fryer that you never knew possible.